Now play nice, girls

Bestie's buddy Sadie left several weeks ago, and Bestie has been going out by herself ever since. There just weren't good mare dynamics at the barn to set her up with a new buddy. But it's not optimal for the property to keep her alone long term, especially since I don't want to pay for solo turnout.

For the last couple of weeks she's been turned out adjacent to an older mare, Sienna, whose pasture buddy also left. Bestie and Sienna have been walked out and walked in together and got along fine and also seemed to coexist in their adjacent pastures with no problem. Earlier today Sienna's owner and I received an email from barn owner Julie asking what we thought about trying the two mares together. We agreed to give it a shot if we could both be there.

So tonight we tried it. Tried it - intentional choice of words. I had kind of a feeling when I got to the barn and Bestie was lunging at both of her neighbors through the wire at the top of the stall walls, which she typically only does when she's in heat.

We walked them out (Bestie trotted the whole way, also not a positive sign) and turned them loose, Sienna first, and then a minute later, Bestie. Kind of anticlimactic - Sienna went to one corner and Bestie went to the other. They didn't even look at each other. Sienna was much more interested in Turbo, who was in a paddock a bit down the hill. And Bestie was much more interested in eating grass.

Bestie grazed along the perimeter until she finally munched her way to Sienna's corner. Turbo had been brought in, so Sienna, no longer distracted, seemed to suddenly realize that there was another horse in the paddock with her. They both sniffed each other's faces, then sniffed down each other's bodies from neck to tail, and then moved away from each other. No pinned ears, no squeals, no nothing. "Whew," was my thought.

I whewed too soon. All of a sudden all hell broke loose; it seemed like Bestie moved back toward Sienna, but they both started kicking and I don't even know who launched the first kick. We started making noise and they moved away from each other again, but definitely continued giving each other the hairy eyeball.

We got them clipped into lead ropes and headed inside. I didn't even check Bestie very thoroughly; after giving her a quick onceover and not seeing anything I turned my attention to Dude.

But while I was grazing Dude, Sienna's owner came out to say she had seen blood on Bestie's rear right hind. Very eagle-eyed of her. I took a look at it and Bestie did have a little nick, but nothing at all serious. We lucked out, considering that Sienna has hind shoes on.

Sienna got a gouge on her left rear leg.

After reading a bunch of stuff online tonight, I'm tempted to try them again, but ... 1) with no other horses out there, and 2) when neither mare is in heat. They have both gotten along fine with previous pasture mates. We're just asking for peaceful coexistence, girls. Not much.